Peter thomas roth instant firmx eye temporary eye tightener reviews

Overall Rating : 3.55 / 5 (11 Reviews)

11 Reviews

• 5 5 star reviews
• 2 4 star reviews
• 0 3 star reviews
• 2 2 star reviews
• 2 1 star reviews

Where reviews refer to foods or cosmetic products, results may vary from person to person. Customer reviews are independent and do not represent the views of The Hut Group.

Eye cream

1

Not a fan of this. It leaves a white residue. It burned my skin. It leaves your eyes feeling really dry.

Report this review

My most important product!

5

I’m in my 60’s but often mistaken for being much younger. I’m blessed with pretty good skin but under eye bags have been an issue for years ( that is until I found this product). The trick is to use very little , I “ cradle” the tube in my right hand ( seems to give me best control) and squeeze 2 very small amts onto top of my left hand .; using 1 finger; pat gently under each eye. Using too much turns into a mess so the product lasts does last a long time! Pretty sure I look 15 years older without this product!!

Report this review

Terrific product!

5

I am in awe of this product! I highly recommend trying it. The trick is to use very little on clean skin. Just pat a little under each eye and don't squint! Simple as that! As soon as it dries, in under 5 mts, you will be truly amazed! I. The last month I have been asked if I am a twin to my sister who is 10 years younger, believe me this has never happened since using this product. I use just his under eyes and carefully apply my foundation. Simple, less is more!!

Report this review

peter roth instant eye

5

would just like to say this product rocks, my under eye bags are totally gone, some white colour after it dries but just put on one of the old eye creams i have, this product is great well worth money

Report this review

Great Product Good Value

5

This does exactly what it was advertised to do, you will not be disappointed.

Report this review

Roth Eye firmy cream

5

This stuff really works, use lightly! And use with a tiny bit of light eye cream so that you don't get a white flaky appearance under your eyes. Lasts forever.

Report this review

LOVE IT - HATE IT

2

This product does work - I have bags under my eyes and it really makes them go away - BUT I cannot get the white bumpy look of the product to go away - so it looks like I have white crumbles under my eyes. I have tried mixing with under eye makeup, but it is all bumpy under my eyes that I end up wiping it all off! Please if anyone has any tricks let me know - because it does work.

Report this review

Peter Thomas Roth instant eye firming gel

4

The white residue is a bother and wahing it with a splash of water sometimes takes too much off.It dose reduce the bags under my eyes which makes me look tired and drawn. For that reason I will use it and recommend it to others

Report this review

THIS DID NOT WORK FOR ME!

2

This is not for every one. Dr. Oz recommended it but because of my sensitive skin, the cream burned and when it dried it was harsh and abrasive trying to wipe off.It may work for others but it definitely did not work for me.

Report this review

Pity. Save Your Money!

1

I purchased this thinking I'd found my miracle eye cream for my baggy, droopy eyes. It worked great, that is until it dried leaving a white residue. Once you wipe away the residue, of course you wipe away the effect. I tried all the suggestions on the box, but nothing worked. If they could modify the formula to ditch the chalky white residue, I'd love this stuff. For now? I'll stick with Oil of Olay and my baggy eyes.

Report this review

Beauty

Bye, Bye Botox.

Photo Courtesy of Gabriela Garcia

Last Updated
Feb 10, 2022

Welcome to Editorialist’s “Hype or Holy Grail”—a biweekly series where our beauty editors test cult-favorite beauty products to determine if they’re all hype or truly a holy grail product worth your hard-earned cash.

Tons of skincare products promise fast results but fail to deliver (trust us, we've tested them all). So when 54-year-old Trinidad Sandoval demonstrated on TikTok how Peter Thomas Roth's Instant FIRMx Temporary Eye Tightener completely erased her heavy under-eye bags, we were intrigued. The viral video left millions of people in awe as Sandoval applied a small amount of the cream under one eye (leaving the other untouched) and, in less than three minutes, the skin appeared significantly tighter, firmer, and more lifted. It was like movie magic. But unlike the movies, this skincare potion isn't kept behind lock and key. It's available to purchase by anyone in need of a wrinkle overhaul—and I'm that person. Eager to find out if Sandoval had some TikTok trickery up her sleeve, I tested Peter Thomas Roth’s Instant FIRMx eye cream to see if it's just all hype or a true holy grail product.

Pros

• Instant results
• Non-greasy
• Silky texture
• A little goes a long way

Cons

• Results are short-lived
• Cannot be used with water-based products
• Leaves a white cast

First, a Little About My Skin

While I don’t have heavy under-eye bags, I do have 11 lines (the two vertical lines between the eyebrows) that make me feel very self-conscious. On top of that, I’ve developed crow’s feet around my eyes, which are especially noticeable when I smile. All that comes with the territory when you’re over forty (which I am), hence my strong desire for Botox treatments. But before I go down that path, I’m putting in the work to uncover non-invasive solutions to address my problem areas. I’ve tested eye creams, anti-aging serums, and I massage my face religiously every night with my trusty gua-sha tools, but nothing seems to make a dent in getting rid of my pesky 11 lines. And while I understand that many of these solutions take time to see visible results, sometimes I just want a quick fix to feel confident about my appearance. Since the Instant FIRMx eye cream has the stamp of approval from Sandoval (and thousands of other loyal users), I decided to give it a go.

More Products We Put to the Test

How Does Peter Thomas Roth's Instant FIRMx Temporary Eye Tightener Work?

The Instant FIRMx eye cream is formulated with Firm-A-Tite, a combination of seaweed extract and sodium silicate that provides instant firming and tightening benefits that can last anywhere from six to eight hours. Seaweed extract helps soothe and soften the complexion, while sodium silicate constricts and lifts the skin, giving it a smoother and more youthful appearance.

However, sodium silicate’s effectiveness is cut short when it comes in contact with water (or any water-based product). Therefore, if you want to use a moisturizer, the brand recommends allowing it to fully absorb and dry before applying the Instant FIRMx eye cream. Additionally, “If you have oilier skin or perspire more, it will break the bond, and the effects of the formula may wear off sooner,” shares a brand representative.

It's important to note that, although this eye cream provides a temporary fix, it also boasts long-term benefits. Packed with ingredients like Eyeliss (a powerful peptide complex), Eye Regener (potent plant extracts of lupine and alfalfa), and vitamins C and E (antioxidants that protect and repair the skin), the cream can help visibly reduce the appearance of fine lines, crow's feet, and undereye bags with continued use. Short-term fixes and long-term results? I'm here for that.

How to Apply

Shake the tube and squeeze a pea-size amount out on top of your hand. Using your fingertips or a clean makeup brush (I found that a makeup brush works best), pick up a tiny amount of product and spread a thin layer onto the eye area, avoiding the eyelids. Let the product dry for approximately five minutes, during which time you should avoid moving your face (i.e., no squinting or smiling).

Due to its potency, you only need a tiny amount to see visible results, which is good because one tube will last considerably longer than your average eye cream. Also, because sodium silicate has a powdery finish, you may notice a white cast left on the skin if you use too much of it, which can look unflattering (especially if you’re melanin-rich). If you notice any white residue, moisten a cotton swab (or your fingertip) and remove the excess by gently patting the edges.

After applying the eye cream, you can gently dab on makeup such as eyeshadow, under-eye concealer, or powder. However, to prolong the effects of the product, you should avoid using water-based makeup or any setting spray, as this will affect the longevity of your results.

Read More Like This

My Results

I tested the Instant FIRMx eye cream on my 11 lines and crow's feet on clean, dry skin. In a matter of 30 seconds, I could see my skin tightening up. I could also feel it tightening, like a layer of Elmer's Glue drying on my skin. I used way too much. The entire day my eye area felt like it was in a mummified cast, unable to move. I eventually washed the product off and vowed to use just a tiny amount the next day.

On day two, after cleansing, I applied moisturizer on my face and made sure it was completely dried and fully absorbed before applying the Instant FIRMx eye cream. This time, using a clean makeup brush, I applied a thin layer of the product, and, to my surprise, it worked just as well as the day before, but without the uncomfortable cast-like feeling. My 11 lines and crow's feet vanished, leaving my skin looking smooth and glass-like.

I dabbed the rest of my face with concealer and foundation (they are water-based so I made sure to avoid the treated area) and then set my entire face with my go-to setting powder. This helps unify the texture of my complexion, so you can't tell what part is tightened and what part is not.

And I know what you're thinking: Can I use this eye cream on other parts of the body, like a saggy neck or post-partum belly? According to the brand, this eye cream is ophthalmologist-tested and specifically formulated for the thinner, delicate, and less porous skin around your eye area. "As such, we recommend that you only use this product as directed—on the under-eye area, crow's feet, 11 lines between the brows, and beneath and above the brow bone, but not on the moveable eyelid," notes a brand rep.

Final Verdict: Holy Grail

It’s a holy grail, through and through. I can confirm that Sandoval's TikTok video involved no sneaky editing whatsoever. This eye cream does what it promises to do: Firm and tighten the delicate skin around the eyes. And when applied correctly, the tightening effects can give you a more youthful appearance for up to eight hours. I love the fact that a tiny amount is all that is needed to notice a visible change; however, the fact that the formula's potency dissolves when in contact with water is a huge bummer. The good news is that there are ways to work around this— like allowing your skincare products to fully dry and absorb before applying the cream or avoiding the treated area when applying makeup. Plus, because of its non-sticky texture, you can reapply when needed throughout the day, should the effects start to wear off. If you are struggling with under-eye bags, loose skin, or deep-set wrinkles, I highly recommend this magic cream.

How long does Peter Thomas Roth FIRMx eye tightener last?

How does Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx eye work?

Can you wear makeup over Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx eye?

What are the ingredients in Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx eye?