Why is the 1st amendment so important

It’s First Amendment week at Simpson College.  We’ve just wrapped up (literally) our Freedom of Speech Wall and finished the annual Constitution Day lecture. So, to close out the week, we thought as the Simpsonian’s Editorial Board, we’d give our thoughts on why the First Amendment is so important.

The question of, ‘Why is the First Amendment necessary?’ is easy to answer. It guarantees us our right to report, but it’s a bit more complex than that. It also ensures you, as readers, can respond to our work and the work of other journalists with criticism without consequences. 

The First Amendment guarantees U.S. citizens the right to speech, religion, press, assembly, and the right to petition the government. Despite the magnitude these rights themselves carry in U.S. society, they trickle down even further to college campuses.  

According to a study run by the Knight Foundation and Gallup, close to 7 in 10 college students (approximately 68%)  regard citizens’ free speech rights as “extremely important” to democracy. The same study found that roughly the same percentage (69%) believe an inclusive society that is welcoming to diverse groups is “extremely important.”

The Simpson College community merged these two values phenomenally last year on Sept. 2 during our college’s protest for racial justice. We were able to assemble and speak out against the faults and inadequacies of our own institution without fear of disciplinary action—all thanks to the powers vested in us by the First Amendment. 

At the same time, it is also important to acknowledge the longstanding, ongoing issue of who gets to enjoy free speech rights in the United States, how these rights are enforced, and whose voices are being heard.

When it comes to standing up for racial injustice, the list of free speech violations is not a short one. While reading a list of names of Black lives taken by police, valedictorian Rooha Haghar’s mic was turned off in the middle of her speech. A federal judge blocked an “anti-riot law” on the grounds that it violates protestors’ First Amendment rights. The over-policing of protests, organizers and activists – such as in Ferguson, is well documented. 

There’s an irony in championing liberty in expression for all while ignoring those who have not historically been able to enjoy free speech or participate in the so-called marketplace of ideas equally. It is important to properly discuss and engage the First Amendment and decide what it means–reckon with its blindspots as well as its privileges–rather than celebrate it uncritically.

Written and broadcasted media challenges the actions of those in power, even if the reporting strives for objectivity, could be subjected to legal action above libel.

According to the Freedom Forum Institute, 64% of people agree public school students should be allowed to report on controversial issues in their student newspapers without the approval of school authorities, compared to 34% who don’t agree. This shows that students appreciate their voices heard as well, without the censorship given by authorities. 

Despite this, the First Amendment does not always give students the right to say whatever they feel needs to be said in schools. If a school, like Simpson College, is privately owned, First Amendment rights do not apply to students; they’re not a guaranteed right for private schools – however, this should not stop you from petitioning to say what you feel needs to be said. 

Additionally, the First Amendment gives you the right to criticize us – something of which we are not immune. If you have a problem, you have the right to express it. Whether that be on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram or email – you have the power to use your voice. 

We encourage you to use your First Amendment and use it right. Be informed and be passionate. 

This is why The Simpsonian hosts First Amendment week each year.

Find out how your most important freedoms are protected by the U.S. Constitution.

About 230 years ago, the nation’s founders drafted the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution to safeguard Americans’ most important individual freedoms. What do these protections mean for you? Read on to find out.

Imagine you live in a country where you aren’t allowed to say or write what you think. The government controls what websites you can visit. If you speak out against these limits, you’ll end up in jail. 

Thankfully, that isn’t how things work in the United States. Many of our basic rights are protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Disagree with a new law in your town? You can speak up about it. Worship differently than your friends do? You have the right to follow any faith you choose or none at all. Want the latest scoop? Read, watch, or listen to as many news sources as you like—or start your own.

We sometimes take these rights for granted, but our nation’s founders did not. Even as they signed the Constitution in 1787, some of the Framers worried that the document didn’t guarantee Americans’ individual freedoms. They wanted to make sure the government they’d created didn’t overstep its bounds.

So James Madison, who had been the main author of the Constitution, wrote the Bill of Rights. Ratified, or approved, in 1791, the 10 amendments that make up the Bill of Rights protect key individual liberties, such as freedom from unreasonable searches and the right to public trials. The first one on the list, however, is arguably the most vital.

The First Amendment establishes Americans’ freedom of speech, religion, and the press, as well as the right to assemble peacefully and petition the government for change. It’s just 45 words—the text fits inside a single tweet! Yet the First Amendment gives Americans incredible power, says Catherine Ross, a law professor at George Washington University.

“It gives us the right to criticize the powerful, to demand change, and to learn what is going on in our society so we can organize for political action and be informed voters,” she says.

Read on to learn more about the First Amendment—and how it applies to teens like you. After all, knowing your rights is the best way to make sure you use them.

THE FIRST AMENDMENT

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Here’s a breakdown of the freedoms it preserves.

Here’s a breakdown of the freedoms it preserves.

Freedom of Religion

Freedom of Religion

In some countries, the government declares an official religion that people have no choice but to follow. But the First Amendment guarantees, or promises, that Americans can practice any religion they choose. They can also choose to practice no religion at all. 

Q: Is prayer allowed in public schools?

A: The Founders wanted to keep the government out of religion. They wrote the establishment clause of the First Amendment—“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion”—to prohibit the government from designating a national religion. What does this mean in school? Generally, you can pray, as long as you’re the one who initiates it and school officials aren’t involved.

Q: Do I have to say the Pledge of Allegiance? It includes the words under God.

A: Schools are allowed to lead students in the Pledge as a patriotic exercise, not as a prayer. But whether you actually say the Pledge is up to you. In 1943, the Supreme Court ruled in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette that students have the right not to salute the flag or recite the Pledge.

Freedom of Speech

Freedom of Speech

The First Amendment guarantees your right to voice your ideas—even if they’re unpopular. Freedom of speech doesn’t protect just spoken words, though. It also protects how you express yourself in the emails you send, in any artwork you create, and even through your hairstyle and the clothes you wear. Like all our rights, however, free speech has limits. In school, for example, you don’t have the right to disrupt your class or say things that hurt other students. Also, the First Amendment prevents only government institutions—like public schools and the police—from punishing or limiting speech. The rules don’t apply to private companies, private schools, or private people like, say, your parents. 

Q: Does the First Amendment allow me to say and wear whatever I want at school?

A: It’s not quite that simple. School officials have the right to limit your clothing choices and speech if they think either might interfere with learning. But schools can’t ban personal expression simply because it’s controversial or unpopular. Case in point: In 1965, Mary Beth Tinker, 13, was suspended for wearing a black armband to school to protest the Vietnam War. She sued the district, and the case made it to the Supreme Court.

The Court ruled in her favor, saying that she had a right to peacefully express her views. In the 1969 decision Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, the justices declared that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” The ruling is still considered one of the most important of all school-related First Amendment cases.

Q: Snapchat locked my account! Isn’t that a violation of free speech?

A: Nope. The First Amendment prevents the government and government institutions—like public schools—from punishing or censoring speech. But the rules don’t apply to private companies, private schools, or private people like, say, your parents. (“You don’t have First Amendment rights at home,” notes Ross.)

These days, social media platforms increasingly feel like public spaces. Still, it’s perfectly legal for private companies such as Snapchat, Twitter, and Facebook to block you as they see fit.

Freedom of the Press

Freedom of the Press

Americans can publish factual information without fear of having it censored by the government. This isn’t the case in a lot of other countries. In China, for example, the government strictly controls the news. It often shuts down websites to prevent people from reading news that makes the government look bad.

Q: We have to show the principal our school newspaper articles before we print them. Is that legal?

A: It sure is. The Supreme Court ruled in 1988’s Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier that administrators have the right to preview and censor school-sponsored publications. School newspapers and yearbooks “are considered to be the school’s speech, so the school does have a say in what’s going to go in there,” says Lata Nott of the First Amendment Center at the Freedom Forum Institute.

Administrators need to have real cause to yank articles, however. In the Kuhlmeier case, the principal pulled certain articles that he thought invaded some students’ privacy.

Q: Does freedom of the press allow the media to write or air whatever it wants?

A: Mostly. Journalists can cover anything they choose and from any viewpoint, whether impartial or intentionally biased. However, there are two key limits. First, journalists are not allowed to knowingly print false information about someone. Second, they cannot print private information, such as medical or financial details, about someone unless the information is important for the public to know.

The threat of a lawsuit is enough to keep most journalists from crossing the line, Nott says. The profession also has a history of self-policing to maintain fair and accurate reporting standards—such as verifying sources and facts before publication. In addition, most respected newspapers keep opinions separate from the news.

Freedom of Assembly

Freedom of Assembly

The right to assemble means people can gather peacefully to express or defend their beliefs.

This can be as simple as joining a group, such as the Girl Scouts or a political party. It also means Americans have the right to gather to protest laws or the actions of companies or organizations they don’t agree with.

Q: My town has a curfew for teens. Doesn’t that violate my right to peacefully assemble?

A: No. In fact, hundreds of U.S. cities have instituted nightly curfews for teens to help reduce crime. Millions of teens have been arrested for violating them. While the government can’t decide who can gather based on a group’s viewpoint, it can dictate the place, time, and manner in which people assemble.

Curfews have been challenged on various grounds, including that they violate teens’ right to gather. But most courts have upheld them. “The reasoning is that minors have lesser rights than adults, need to be safe, and . . . that the community also needs to be safe from disorderly young people,” Ross says. Still, courts have blocked curfews that are too broad or don’t have enough exclusions—such as for teens who work night jobs.

Freedom to Petition the Government

Freedom to Petition the Government

To petition means to make a formal written request. Americans exercise their right to petition the government anytime they send an email or a letter to an elected official about a problem they want solved. In the U.S., all voices are considered important. An easy way to exercise this right is to visit usa.gov/elected-officials. There, you can send a message to the president, your state governor, and other officials about issues that matter most to you.

Q: Can I use social media to ask my classmates to lobby school officials?

A: In general, the right to complain to the authorities isn’t up for debate. After all, the Declaration of Independence was mostly a list of complaints about British rule. Just as we all have the right to complain to lawmakers, students have the right to lobby school officials for changes. But you can’t encourage actions that would disrupt learning.

How you make demands also matters, as Connecticut teen Avery Doninger found out. In 2007, she wrote a blog post urging fellow students to complain to school officials after they canceled a concert. But she insulted administrators in her post—and the school blocked Avery from serving on the student council as a result. She sued, but the courts eventually sided with the school, saying that Avery’s post had disrupted other students.

Learn from that, Nott suggests. “If your goal is to actually lobby the administration, leave out the insults,” she says. Otherwise, “you’re risking that your message will get lost.”

How does the First Amendment impact our lives?

Which 1st Amendment right is most important?

What would happen without the First Amendment?